Organic Chemistry II · Enols and enolates

Aldol reaction and aldol condensation practice, with the mechanism step by step

About 25 min read · Report a mistake

An aldol reaction joins two carbonyl compounds with one new carbon–carbon bond. One partner gives up an α-hydrogen and becomes the nucleophile (the enolate). The other partner's C=O carbon is the electrophile. If you can find those two carbons, you can predict the product, run the reaction backwards, and see why some mixtures give one clean product while others give four. This page builds that skill, then gives you 17 practice problems with full solutions.

Jump to: the one bond · α-hydrogens and bases · mechanism, step by step · addition vs condensation · acid version · crossed aldols · ring-forming aldols · working backwards · worked examples · exam traps · practice · FAQ

Want to test yourself first? Practice Enols and enolates in the app. Chapters 1 and 11 are free with no login; this chapter opens with the free trial (email only, no card).

Try a practice problem now

The one bond every aldol makes

Every aldol, simple or tricky, makes the same bond: from the α-carbon of the donor to the carbonyl carbon of the acceptor. Throughout this page the donor carbon has a solid underline and the acceptor carbon has a dotted underline.

Donor (nucleophile)

Needs at least one H on the carbon next to its C=O (an α-hydrogen). Base removes that H to make an enolate. The enolate's α-carbon does the attacking.

Acceptor (electrophile)

Any aldehyde or ketone C=O. Its carbon is δ+. Aldehydes are better acceptors than ketones because they are less crowded and less stabilized.

Skeletal structures. Left: 3-hydroxybutanal, the aldol addition product, with the new bond between C2 (alpha) and C3 (beta) highlighted and an OH on C3. Right: but-2-enal, the condensation product, with a C2=C3 double bond conjugated to the C=O. OHHO αβ HO αβ aldol (addition)enal (condensation) →heat, −H₂O
Two acetaldehyde molecules give 3-hydroxybutanal (left). The thick bond is the new C–C bond from the α-carbon to the old C=O carbon, which is now the β-carbon carrying the OH. Heat removes water to give but-2-enal (right), with the C=C between the α and β carbons.

The name comes from the product: an aldehyde plus an alcohol in the same molecule. The general pattern is a β-hydroxy carbonyl (the OH sits two carbons from the C=O). Lose water and you get an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl, called an enone for a ketone or an enal for an aldehyde.

Step zero: find the α-hydrogens and pick a base

The α-carbon is the one directly attached to the C=O carbon. Its hydrogens are unusually acidic for C–H bonds because the anion left behind shares its charge with the oxygen (the enolate has two resonance forms, one with the charge on carbon and one with it on oxygen). If a carbonyl compound has no α-hydrogens, it can never be the donor.

How acidic is the α-H? (pKa values from OpenStax Table 22.1)
Compound typeExamplepKa of the α-H
KetoneAcetone, CH₃COCH₃19.3 (about 19–20 for ketones)
AldehydeAcetaldehyde, CH₃CHOabout 17
EsterCH₃CO₂CH₃about 25
1,3-Diketone2,4-Pentanedioneabout 9 (H between two C=O)

Now compare with the conjugate acid of the base. The bigger that pKa, the further the equilibrium goes toward the enolate. A difference of one pKa unit is a factor of 10.

Which base makes how much enolate from acetone (pKa 19.3)?
BaseConjugate acid pKaK for acetone + baseWhat that means
NaOH15.7 (H₂O)1015.7 − 19.3 ≈ 3 × 10⁻⁴A tiny amount of enolate at any moment. That is enough for an aldol, because the enolate is constantly re-formed.
NaOEt16 (EtOH)1016 − 19.3 ≈ 5 × 10⁻⁴Same story. OpenStax puts acetone deprotonation by ethoxide at about 0.1%.
LDA, LiN(i-Pr)₂36 (diisopropylamine)1036 − 19.3 ≈ 5 × 10¹⁶Essentially complete. All of the ketone becomes enolate before you add anything else.

That difference is the key to crossed aldols later on. With NaOH, enolate and neutral carbonyl sit side by side, so the compound reacts with itself. With LDA, you can turn one compound completely into enolate first and then choose its partner. If ranking acids by pKa still feels shaky, the ranking acidity practice problems cover it.

The mechanism, one step at a time

Here is acetaldehyde with NaOH: three steps to the aldol product, then two more with heat to the enal. With JavaScript on, use the Next and Back buttons to go one step at a time. Each step lists its curved arrows in words.

  1. Step 1: base removes an α-H (enolate forms)

    H–CH₂–CHO + ⁻OH ⇌ ⁻:CH₂–CH=O ↔ CH₂=CH–O⁻ + H₂O

    • Arrow 1: a lone pair on hydroxide's O goes to the α-H.
    • Arrow 2: the C–H bond electrons stay on the α-carbon. They spread onto oxygen by resonance (the enolate).

    This equilibrium lies on the left (pKa 17 vs 15.7), but a little enolate is all you need.

  2. Step 2: the enolate attacks a second C=O

    ⁻:CH₂–CHO + CH₃–CH=O → CH₃–CH(O⁻)–CH₂–CHO

    • Arrow 1: the α-carbon's electron pair goes to the acceptor's C=O carbon, making the new C–C bond.
    • Arrow 2: the C=O π electrons move up onto oxygen, giving an alkoxide.

    This is a nucleophilic addition, just like a Grignard adding to a C=O. Here the carbon nucleophile is the enolate.

  3. Step 3: the alkoxide picks up a proton

    CH₃–CH(O⁻)–CH₂–CHO + H₂O → CH₃–CH(OH)–CH₂–CHO + ⁻OH

    • Arrow 1: an O⁻ lone pair takes an H from water.
    • Arrow 2: the O–H bond electrons go to the water oxygen, giving back hydroxide.

    This gives 3-hydroxybutanal, the aldol addition product. Hydroxide comes back, so the base is a catalyst. Stop here if the reaction is kept cold.

  4. Step 4 (with heat): remove the α-H again

    CH₃–CH(OH)–CH₂–CHO + ⁻OH ⇌ CH₃–CH(OH)–CH⁻–CHO + H₂O

    • Arrow 1: hydroxide takes an H from the α-carbon, the one sitting between the C=O and the C–OH.
    • Arrow 2: those C–H electrons become the enolate's lone pair, shared with the C=O oxygen.

    That α-H is still acidic, because it is still next to the C=O.

  5. Step 5 (with heat): the enolate pushes out hydroxide (E1cB)

    CH₃–CH(OH)–CH⁻–CHO → CH₃–CH=CH–CHO + ⁻OH

    • Arrow 1: the enolate's electron pair forms a C=C between the α and β carbons.
    • Arrow 2: the C–OH bond breaks, and hydroxide leaves.

    The product is but-2-enal, an α,β-unsaturated aldehyde. Hydroxide is normally a poor leaving group, but here it leaves from a carbanion next to a C=O. The C=C that forms is conjugated with the C=O, which makes the product more stable. That mechanism is called E1cB: elimination, unimolecular, through the conjugate base.

Atom check: 2 C₂H₄O → C₄H₈O₂ (3-hydroxybutanal), then − H₂O → C₄H₆O (but-2-enal). An aldol never changes the atoms, it only joins the two molecules. Condensation then removes one H₂O.

Addition or condensation? Read the conditions

What the conditions tell you
Conditions you seeProduct to drawWhy
Dilute NaOH or NaOEt, cold (0–5 °C), "aldol addition"β-Hydroxy aldehyde or ketoneSteps 1–3 only. Not enough energy for the E1cB steps.
NaOH or NaOEt with heat, "aldol condensation"α,β-Unsaturated carbonyl (enone or enal) + H₂OSteps 4–5 run too. The conjugated C=C makes the product more stable.
Acid (H₂SO₄, HCl) with heatUsually the enoneThe acid version dehydrates easily (see the next section).
1. LDA, THF, −78 °C; 2. second carbonyl; 3. H₂O workupβ-Hydroxy carbonyl from a chosen pairA preformed (directed) enolate. Cold, so it usually stops at addition.

Why heat matters for ketones. OpenStax 23.1 says the aldol equilibrium favors the product for simple aldehydes (RCH₂CHO), but favors the starting materials for most ketones and for α,α-disubstituted aldehydes (R₂CHCHO). Crowding is the likely reason. For example, cyclohexanone gives only 22% of its aldol addition product. Dehydration rescues the ketone. Removing water pulls the whole equilibrium forward, so cyclohexanone with heat gives the enone in 92% yield (OpenStax 23.3).

Where the C=C goes. Always between the α and β carbons, conjugated with the C=O. When the C=C can be cis or trans, the more stable E (trans) isomer is usually the major product.

The acid-catalyzed version, briefly

In acid there is no enolate. The nucleophile is the neutral enol, and the electrophile is a protonated (more reactive) C=O.

  1. Acid protonates the C=O oxygen of one molecule, and water removes an α-H. That makes the enol, C=C–OH.
  2. The C=O of a second molecule is protonated, which makes its carbon much more electrophilic.
  3. The enol's C=C attacks that carbon (forming the new C–C bond), and the former enol oxygen loses its H⁺ to become C=O again. That gives the β-hydroxy carbonyl.
  4. With acid and heat the OH is protonated, water leaves, and the α-H is lost (E1 or E2, through the enol). That gives the conjugated enone.

The product skeleton is the same as with base. Only the intermediates change: enol instead of enolate, and a protonated carbonyl instead of a neutral one. Acid-catalyzed aldols usually go all the way to the conjugated product.

Spotting the donor and acceptor carbons gets fast with reps. Practice enolate chemistry and every other Orgo chapter with feedback on each step.

Start practicing free

3 days, every chapter. No card.

Crossed (mixed) aldols: why you get four products, and how to get one

Mix two different carbonyls that both have α-hydrogens, such as propanal and butanal, with NaOH. Each one can be the donor and each can be the acceptor, so you get two self-aldols and two crossed aldols: four products, all hard to separate. The fix is always to take away choices.

Propanal + butanal + NaOH: every donor/acceptor pairing happens
Donor (enolate from) ↓ / Acceptor →Propanal C=OButanal C=O
Propanal3-hydroxy-2-methylpentanal (self)3-hydroxy-2-methylhexanal (crossed)
Butanal2-ethyl-3-hydroxypentanal (crossed)2-ethyl-3-hydroxyhexanal (self)

Three ways to get a single crossed product

  1. Use one partner with no α-H. Benzaldehyde or formaldehyde can only be acceptors. Their exposed carbonyl groups are good acceptors, the enolizable partner mostly attacks them instead of itself. To help further, add the enolizable partner slowly to the aldehyde and base, so it rarely meets another molecule of itself.
  2. Claisen–Schmidt: a ketone with an aromatic aldehyde. This is the classic case of fix 1. The ketone (acetone, acetophenone, cyclohexanone) is the donor. The aromatic aldehyde is the acceptor. The ketone's own self-aldol is unfavorable, and the product dehydrates to an enone conjugated with the ring, which pulls everything forward. Example: benzaldehyde + acetone + NaOH gives 4-phenylbut-3-en-2-one (benzalacetone). With two equivalents of benzaldehyde, both sides of acetone react, giving dibenzalacetone.
  3. Preform one enolate with LDA. Treat the donor with LDA in THF at −78 °C, so it becomes 100% enolate and there is no neutral donor left to attack. Then add the acceptor. The compound you put in with LDA first is the nucleophile. Order of addition decides the product. (A partner that is far more acidic, like a 1,3-dicarbonyl, also works with weaker bases, because it is completely deprotonated first.)

Ring-forming (intramolecular) aldols: 5 and 6 win

When one molecule has two C=O groups, an enolate can attack the other C=O in the same molecule and close a ring. Usually more than one α-carbon could do the attacking, so there is more than one possible ring size. Every step is reversible, so the reaction settles on the most stable product: a five- or six-membered ring. Three- and four-membered rings are too strained to win (OpenStax 23.6).

How to count the ring: start at the attacking α-carbon, walk along the chain to the C=O carbon it attacks, and count every carbon on the way, including both ends.

Common ring-forming aldols (NaOH, heat)
Starting materialRing choicesProduct
Hexane-2,5-dione (a 1,4-diketone)CH₃ end (C1) attacks C5: 5 ring. C3 attacks C5: 3 ring.3-Methylcyclopent-2-en-1-one
Heptane-2,6-dione (a 1,5-diketone)C1 attacks C6: 6 ring. C3 attacks C6: 4 ring.3-Methylcyclohex-2-en-1-one
Octane-2,7-dione (a 1,6-diketone)C3 attacks C7: 5 ring. C1 attacks C7: 7 ring.1-(2-Methylcyclopent-1-en-1-yl)ethan-1-one (acetyl group outside the ring)

Notice the pattern. For 1,4- and 1,5-diketones the ring is made using the CH₃ at the end of the chain. For a 1,6-diketone the ring is made using a CH₂ inside the chain, and the other carbonyl ends up outside the ring as an acetyl group.

Working backwards (retro-aldol thinking)

Synthesis questions give you the enone and ask what it came from. The aldol leaves a fingerprint: a C=O with a C=C at α,β (or an OH at β). Undo it in three moves:

  1. Label it. Find the C=O. The next carbon is α, the one after is β.
  2. Cut between α and β. For an enone, cut the C=C. For a β-hydroxy carbonyl, cut the single bond.
  3. Repair both halves. The β-carbon gets a C=O (it was the acceptor; the OH or the C=C came from that oxygen). The α-carbon gets back its hydrogens: two for an enone (one lost making the enolate, one lost in dehydration), one for a β-hydroxy carbonyl.

If the two halves are the same compound, it was a self-aldol. If one half has no α-H, like benzaldehyde, you have a clean crossed aldol. If both halves have α-H, you need the LDA method in the forward direction.

The real retro-aldol reaction. Because the aldol is an equilibrium, base can also run it backwards. Hydroxide removes the β-OH proton, the alkoxide re-forms a C=O, and the α–β bond breaks to release an enolate. Heating diacetone alcohol (4-hydroxy-4-methylpentan-2-one) with base gives back two acetones this way. Your cells do the same thing in glycolysis, where the enzyme aldolase splits fructose 1,6-bisphosphate into two three-carbon sugars.

Worked examples

Each example uses the same five checks: donor, acceptor, new bond, water or not, and an atom count.

Example 1: self-aldol of pentanal, cold and then hot

Pentanal (CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂CHO) is treated with NaOH at 5 °C. What forms, and what forms if the mixture is then heated?

  1. Donor: the α-carbon is C2 (the CH₂ next to the CHO). Its enolate is ⁻CH(CH₂CH₂CH₃)–CHO. C2 carries a propyl group, and that becomes a branch.
  2. Acceptor: the CHO carbon (C1) of a second pentanal.
  3. New bond: C2 of molecule 1 to C1 of molecule 2. After protonation: OHC–CH(CH₂CH₂CH₃)–CH(OH)–CH₂CH₂CH₂CH₃.
  4. Name it: the longest chain through the CHO runs CHO, the branch carbon, the CH(OH), then the butyl group: 7 carbons. So it is 3-hydroxy-2-propylheptanal.
  5. With heat: E1cB removes the C2–H and the C3–OH, giving 2-propylhept-2-enal, CH₃CH₂CH₂CH₂CH=C(CH₂CH₂CH₃)CHO (mainly E).

Answer: cold gives 3-hydroxy-2-propylheptanal. Heated, it gives 2-propylhept-2-enal.

Check: 2 × C₅H₁₀O = C₁₀H₂₀O₂ for the aldol, and minus H₂O = C₁₀H₁₈O for the enal. The product is branched at C2, never a straight 10-carbon chain, because the bond is made at the α-carbon.

Example 2: a Claisen–Schmidt reaction (making chalcone)

Benzaldehyde (C₆H₅CHO) and acetophenone (C₆H₅COCH₃) are stirred with NaOH in ethanol. Predict the main product.

  1. Donor: only acetophenone has α-hydrogens (on its CH₃). Benzaldehyde's CHO carbon is attached straight to the ring, so it has no α-H.
  2. Acceptor: benzaldehyde's CHO carbon. It is a far better acceptor than acetophenone's ketone C=O, and acetophenone's self-aldol is unfavorable anyway.
  3. New bond: the CH₃ carbon of acetophenone to the CHO carbon. Addition product: C₆H₅CO–CH₂–CH(OH)–C₆H₅.
  4. Water or not: this one dehydrates easily even at room temperature. The C=C it forms is conjugated with both the C=O and the benzene ring.
  5. Product: C₆H₅CO–CH=CH–C₆H₅, (E)-1,3-diphenylprop-2-en-1-one, called chalcone.

Answer: (E)-chalcone, C₆H₅COCH=CHC₆H₅.

Check: C₇H₆O + C₈H₈O = C₁₅H₁₄O₂, minus H₂O = C₁₅H₁₂O. Only one donor and one good acceptor, so there is one main product.

Example 3: closing a ring from heptane-2,6-dione

Heptane-2,6-dione, CH₃COCH₂CH₂CH₂COCH₃, is heated with NaOH. What ring forms?

  1. Number it: C1 (CH₃), C2 (C=O), C3, C4, C5, C6 (C=O), C7 (CH₃). The α-carbons are C1, C3, C5 and C7.
  2. Try each donor against the other C=O: C1 attacking C6 closes C1–C2–C3–C4–C5–C6, a 6-membered ring. C3 attacking C6 closes C3–C4–C5–C6, a 4-membered ring. (C5 and C7 are the mirror images of C3 and C1.)
  3. Pick the winner: the 6-membered ring is nearly strain-free. The 4-membered ring is badly strained, and since every step is reversible, the 6-ring product builds up.
  4. Dehydrate: the C=C forms between the old C1 (α) and C6 (β, which carries the OH and the CH₃).
  5. Name it: ring C=O is C1, the CH= is C2 and the C(CH₃)= is C3. So it is 3-methylcyclohex-2-en-1-one.

Answer: 3-methylcyclohex-2-en-1-one (plus H₂O).

Check: C₇H₁₂O₂ − H₂O = C₇H₁₀O. The ring has 6 carbons, and the seventh carbon is the methyl group. Every carbon is accounted for.

Example 4: working backwards from 2-benzylidenecyclohexanone

What two compounds and what conditions make 2-benzylidenecyclohexan-1-one (a cyclohexanone ring with =CH–C₆H₅ on C2)?

  1. Label it: the ring C=O is C1, so ring C2 is α and the exocyclic =CH–C₆H₅ carbon is β.
  2. Cut α=β: the C=C between ring C2 and the CH.
  3. Repair: the β-carbon becomes a CHO on the benzene ring, which is benzaldehyde. Ring C2 gets its two hydrogens back, which gives cyclohexanone.
  4. Is the forward reaction clean? Yes. Benzaldehyde has no α-H, so this is a Claisen–Schmidt. Use NaOH (or NaOEt) and about one equivalent of benzaldehyde. Excess benzaldehyde also reacts at C6, giving 2,6-dibenzylidenecyclohexanone.

Answer: cyclohexanone + benzaldehyde, NaOH in ethanol (heat if needed). Use one equivalent of benzaldehyde.

Check: C₆H₁₀O + C₇H₆O = C₁₃H₁₆O₂, minus H₂O = C₁₃H₁₄O, which matches the product.

Common exam traps

  • Bonding at the end carbon. The new bond is always at the α-carbon. Self-aldols of straight-chain aldehydes give a branched product with the branch at C2, not a long straight chain.
  • Drawing the enone when it's cold. Cold, dilute base gives the β-hydroxy carbonyl. Draw the C=C only with heat, acid, or when the text says "condensation".
  • Using a no-α-H compound as the donor. Benzaldehyde, formaldehyde, 2,2-dimethylpropanal and benzophenone can never be the enolate.
  • Assuming one product from two enolizable carbonyls with NaOH. You get up to four. Only a no-α-H partner, a much more acidic partner, or a preformed LDA enolate fixes it.
  • Mixing up the LDA order. The compound that meets LDA first is the nucleophile. Swap the order and you get a different product.
  • Putting the C=C in the wrong place. It goes between the α and β carbons, conjugated with the C=O. It never ends up in a ring position away from the carbonyl.
  • Counting rings wrong. Count both the attacking α-carbon and the attacked C=O carbon. Three- and four-membered rings don't win.
  • Calling a Claisen an aldol. Esters with NaOEt give β-keto esters by acyl substitution (Claisen condensation). Aldehydes and ketones give β-hydroxy carbonyls or enones (aldol).

Practice problems

Seventeen problems in seven rounds. Every option is explained when you check it, and every problem has a full worked solution. The results table counts first tries only. With JavaScript off, every question and full solution is still here. Open "Show worked solution" to check yourself.

Round 1: Predict the product (3 problems)

Problem 1 · Predict the productButanal (CH₃CH₂CH₂CHO) is stirred with dilute NaOH at 5 °C. What is the main product?

Show worked solution

Answer: 2-ethyl-3-hydroxyhexanal.

  1. Donor: C2 of butanal. Its enolate is ⁻CH(CH₂CH₃)CHO.
  2. Acceptor: the CHO carbon of a second butanal.
  3. New bond C2–C1′: OHC–CH(CH₂CH₃)–CH(OH)–CH₂CH₂CH₃.
  4. Cold, so no dehydration. Longest chain through the CHO: 6 carbons (hexanal), with OH at C3 and ethyl at C2.

Check: 2 × C₄H₈O = C₈H₁₆O₂.

Every option explained

  • A. That is the condensation product. At 5 °C with dilute base the reaction stops before losing water. Heat would give this.
  • B. That is a Cannizzaro reaction. It only happens to aldehydes with no α-H in concentrated base. Butanal has α-hydrogens, so it does an aldol.
  • C (correct). C2 of one butanal (the α-carbon) bonds to C1 of another. Cold, dilute base stops at the β-hydroxy aldehyde, and the ethyl branch is the rest of the donor’s chain.
  • D. A straight chain would need the CH₃ end of butanal to attack. The enolate carbon is C2, next to the CHO, so the product branches at C2.
Problem 2 · Predict the productCyclopentanone is heated with NaOH in ethanol. What is the main product?

Show worked solution

Answer: 2-cyclopentylidenecyclopentan-1-one.

  1. Donor: C2 of one cyclopentanone (an α-carbon). Acceptor: the C=O carbon of another.
  2. Addition gives 2-(1-hydroxycyclopentyl)cyclopentan-1-one. Its OH is on the β-carbon, which is the ring carbon of the second ring.
  3. Heat: hydroxide removes the remaining α-H (ring C2) and the β-OH leaves (E1cB). The C=C joins the two rings, conjugated with the C=O.

Check: 2 × C₅H₈O = C₁₀H₁₆O₂, minus H₂O = C₁₀H₁₄O. OpenStax 23.3 shows the same pattern for cyclohexanone (92% of the enone).

Every option explained

  • A. That is the addition product. With heat it loses water. For ketones the addition step is uphill, so dehydration is what drives the reaction.
  • B (correct). The α-carbon of one ring bonds to the C=O carbon of the other. Then E1cB puts a C=C between them, conjugated with the remaining C=O. Formula C₁₀H₁₄O.
  • C. Same atoms, but the C=C is in the wrong place. E1cB removes the α-H next to the C=O, so the C=C forms between the α and β carbons, conjugated with the C=O. This one is not conjugated.
  • D. That has only 5 carbons. An aldol joins two molecules, so the product has 10.
Problem 3 · Predict the productBenzaldehyde (2 equivalents) and acetone (1 equivalent) are heated with NaOH in ethanol. What is the main product?

Show worked solution

Answer: dibenzalacetone, (1E,4E)-1,5-diphenylpenta-1,4-dien-3-one.

  1. Only acetone can be the donor. Benzaldehyde has no α-H.
  2. The first Claisen–Schmidt condensation on one CH₃ gives C₆H₅CH=CHCOCH₃.
  3. That product still has a CH₃ next to its C=O. With a second benzaldehyde it condenses again on that side.

Check: 2 × C₇H₆O + C₃H₆O = C₁₇H₁₈O₃, minus 2 H₂O = C₁₇H₁₄O.

Every option explained

  • A. That is the product from one benzaldehyde. With two equivalents, the CH₃ on the other side of acetone reacts too.
  • B (correct). Acetone has α-H on both sides. Each CH₃ in turn makes an enolate and condenses with one benzaldehyde. Formula C₁₇H₁₄O.
  • C. That is acetone reacting with itself. Benzaldehyde is a much better acceptor than acetone, and acetone’s self-aldol is uphill, so the crossed reaction wins.
  • D. Cinnamaldehyde comes from benzaldehyde plus acetaldehyde. Here the donor is acetone, so the product keeps a ketone C=O in the middle.

Round 2: Find the nucleophile (2 problems)

Problem 4 · Find the nucleophileAcetophenone (C₆H₅COCH₃) and benzaldehyde (C₆H₅CHO) react with NaOH. Which atom acts as the nucleophile and forms the new C–C bond?

Show worked solution

Answer: the CH₃ carbon of acetophenone.

Benzaldehyde’s CHO carbon is bonded straight to the ring, so it has no α-H and can only be the acceptor. Acetophenone’s CH₃ is its only α-carbon. Its enolate attacks benzaldehyde’s C=O carbon, and after dehydration that gives chalcone (Worked example 2).

Every option explained

  • A. One resonance form of the enolate has the charge on oxygen, but with C=O electrophiles the enolate bonds through carbon. That makes the strong new C–C bond and gives back a C=O.
  • B (correct). It is the only α-carbon in the mixture. Hydroxide removes one of its hydrogens, and that carbon attacks.
  • C. That is the electrophile. It is δ+ and gets attacked.
  • D. The ring is not the nucleophile here. Ring carbons attack only in electrophilic aromatic substitution, which needs a very strong electrophile, not NaOH and a C=O.
Problem 5 · Find the nucleophileCyclohexanone is treated with LDA in THF at −78 °C, then propanal is added, then water. The product is 2-(1-hydroxypropyl)cyclohexan-1-one. Pick the role of each atom.

Show worked solution

Answer: C2 of cyclohexanone is the nucleophile, propanal C1 is the electrophile, the propanal oxygen becomes the OH, and propanal C2 is not involved.

This is why the LDA method gives one product. All of the cyclohexanone is enolate before propanal arrives, so there is no neutral cyclohexanone to attack and no base left to make propanal’s enolate. The new bond joins ring C2 to the CH(OH) carbon: ring–CH(OH)CH₂CH₃.

Check: C₆H₁₀O + C₃H₆O = C₉H₁₆O₂.

Every row explained

  • C2 of cyclohexanone (next to its C=O): Nucleophile (makes the new bond). LDA removed an H from this carbon first, so its enolate is the only nucleophile in the flask.
  • C1 of propanal (the CHO carbon): Electrophile (gets attacked). The CHO carbon is δ+. It is the carbon the enolate attacks.
  • The oxygen of propanal’s C=O: Becomes the OH. The C=O π electrons go onto this oxygen (alkoxide). Water protonates it, giving the OH.
  • C2 of propanal: Not involved. Propanal was added after the LDA was used up on cyclohexanone, so propanal never forms an enolate.

Round 3: Order the steps (2 problems)

Problem 6 · Order the stepsPut the steps of the NaOH-catalyzed aldol condensation of butanal (to 2-ethylhex-2-enal) in order.
  • Step A The alkoxide takes H⁺ from water, giving the β-hydroxy aldehyde.
  • Step B Hydroxide removes an α-H from butanal, giving the enolate.
  • Step C The enolate pushes out hydroxide, forming the conjugated C=C (E1cB).
  • Step D The enolate carbon attacks the C=O carbon of a second butanal, giving an alkoxide.
  • Step E Hydroxide removes the α-H between the C=O and the C–OH.

Show worked solution

Answer: B, D, A, E, C.

  1. B: make the enolate (base takes the α-H).
  2. D: the enolate attacks a second C=O, forming the C–C bond and an alkoxide.
  3. A: protonate the alkoxide. You now have the aldol, 2-ethyl-3-hydroxyhexanal.
  4. E: with heat, remove the α-H again to make a new enolate.
  5. C: that enolate expels ⁻OH (E1cB), giving 2-ethylhex-2-enal.

Hydroxide is used in B and E and given back in A and C, so it is a catalyst.

Problem 7 · Order the stepsHeating diacetone alcohol, (CH₃)₂C(OH)CH₂COCH₃, with NaOH gives two acetones by a retro-aldol. Put the steps in order.
  • Step A The acetone enolate takes H⁺ from water, giving acetone.
  • Step B Hydroxide removes the H from the OH group, giving an alkoxide.
  • Step C The alkoxide re-forms a C=O, and the C–C bond to the α-carbon breaks. That releases one acetone and one acetone enolate.

Show worked solution

Answer: B, C, A.

A retro-aldol is the aldol run backwards. Deprotonating the β-OH (B) gives the same alkoxide as in the forward step. That alkoxide pushes its electrons back down to make a C=O (C), and the electrons of the α–β bond leave as an enolate, a decent leaving group because the C=O stabilizes it. Protonation (A) gives the second acetone. It works here because, for ketones like acetone, the equilibrium favors the starting carbonyls.

Round 4: Pick the conditions (3 problems)

Problem 8 · Pick the conditionsYou want only C₆H₅COCH₂C(OH)(CH₃)₂ (3-hydroxy-3-methyl-1-phenylbutan-1-one) from acetophenone and acetone. Which conditions?

Show worked solution

Answer: LDA on acetophenone first, then acetone, then water.

  1. Work backwards: cut the α–β bond of the target. The β-carbon, C(OH)(CH₃)₂, came from acetone (the acceptor). The α-side, C₆H₅COCH₂–, came from acetophenone (the donor).
  2. Both partners have α-H, so NaOH can’t pick a donor. LDA can: it deprotonates acetophenone completely (K ≈ 10¹⁶ or more).
  3. Adding acetone second makes it the only electrophile. A cold workup leaves the OH in place.

Check: C₈H₈O + C₃H₆O = C₁₁H₁₄O₂.

Every option explained

  • A. Both ketones have α-H, so you get both self-aldols and both crossed aldols. Ketone aldol additions are uphill too, so you would mostly recover starting material.
  • B (correct). LDA turns all the acetophenone into its enolate first. The only C=O it can then meet is acetone’s. The cold conditions stop at the β-hydroxy ketone.
  • C. Wrong order. Now acetone is the nucleophile and acetophenone is the acceptor. That gives CH₃COCH₂C(OH)(CH₃)C₆H₅, which is 4-hydroxy-4-phenylpentan-2-one.
  • D. In acid both ketones can still form enols, so you still get a mixture. Heat would also dehydrate the product, and the target keeps its OH.
Problem 9 · Pick the conditionsWhich pair gives one main crossed aldol product with NaOH?

Show worked solution

Answer: benzaldehyde + acetophenone.

Run the checklist on each pair. Does exactly one partner have α-H? Is the other partner a decent acceptor (an aldehyde)? Only the last pair passes both. It works like a Claisen–Schmidt, except the aldehyde without α-H is aliphatic instead of aromatic.

Every option explained

  • A. Both have α-H, so you get four products, two self and two crossed (see the grid above).
  • B. Both have α-H. Butanal is a good donor and an even better acceptor, so its self-aldol competes. You get a mixture.
  • C. Neither has an α-H, so neither can form an enolate. No aldol at all.
  • D (correct). Benzaldehyde has no α-H, so it can only be the acceptor. Acetophenone is the only donor, and the exposed aldehyde C=O is the better acceptor. The product can dehydrate to chalcone, C₆H₅CH=CHCOC₆H₅.
Problem 10 · Pick the conditionsWhich base turns acetone (pKa 19.3) almost completely into its enolate?

Show worked solution

Answer: LDA.

For acid + base ⇌ conjugate base + conjugate acid, K = 10^(pKa of the conjugate acid formed − pKa of the acid). The conjugate acid of LDA is diisopropylamine (pKa 36), far weaker than acetone (19.3), so K is about 10¹⁷. Every other base on the list has a conjugate acid stronger than acetone, so K is less than 1.

Every option explained

  • A. K ≈ 10^(15.7 − 19.3) ≈ 3 × 10⁻⁴. That is only a trace of enolate at a time. It is fine for an ordinary aldol, but far from complete.
  • B. K ≈ 10^(16 − 19.3) ≈ 5 × 10⁻⁴, about 0.1% enolate by the OpenStax estimate.
  • C. Much too weak: K ≈ 10^(10.7 − 19.3) ≈ 3 × 10⁻⁹.
  • D (correct). K ≈ 10^(36 − 19.3) ≈ 5 × 10¹⁶. The equilibrium lies completely on the enolate side.

Round 5: Work backwards (3 problems)

Problem 11 · Work backwardsWhat made 4-methylpent-3-en-2-one, (CH₃)₂C=CH–CO–CH₃, by an aldol condensation?

Show worked solution

Answer: acetone + acetone (mesityl oxide is acetone’s self-condensation product).

  1. Label: the C=O is C2, the α-carbon is C3 (=CH–), and the β-carbon is C4, =C(CH₃)₂.
  2. Cut C3=C4.
  3. Repair: C4 becomes O=C(CH₃)₂, which is acetone. C3 becomes CH₃ again, giving CH₃COCH₃, also acetone.

Check: 2 × C₃H₆O − H₂O = C₆H₁₀O, which matches (CH₃)₂C=CHCOCH₃.

Every option explained

  • A. That pair gives an aldehyde, 4-methylpent-2-enal. The target is a ketone, so the donor half must be a ketone.
  • B. The β-carbon in the target carries two CH₃ groups, so the acceptor was acetone. Propanal as the acceptor would leave an H and an ethyl group on the β-carbon.
  • C. Formaldehyde would make a CH₂= end; one possible product is 3-methylbut-3-en-2-one. The target has (CH₃)₂C= at that end.
  • D (correct). Cut the C=C. The β-carbon, C(CH₃)₂, gets a C=O, which gives acetone. The α-carbon (CH) gets two H back, which gives CH₃COCH₃, also acetone. So it is a self-aldol.
Problem 12 · Work backwardsWhat two compounds make 2-methyl-3-phenylprop-2-enal, C₆H₅CH=C(CH₃)CHO?

Show worked solution

Answer: benzaldehyde + propanal (NaOH, heat).

  1. Label: CHO is C1, C2 (with the CH₃) is α, and C3 (with the phenyl) is β.
  2. Cut C2=C3.
  3. Repair: C3 gets =O, giving C₆H₅CHO. C2 gets two H back, giving CH₃CH₂CHO.
  4. Forward check: propanal is the only donor, and benzaldehyde is the better acceptor. Adding propanal slowly keeps its self-aldol down.

Check: C₇H₆O + C₃H₆O − H₂O = C₁₀H₁₀O.

Every option explained

  • A (correct). The β-carbon (CH–C₆H₅) becomes benzaldehyde. The α-carbon, carrying the CH₃, gets two H back, which gives CH₃CH₂CHO, propanal. Benzaldehyde has no α-H, so this crossed aldol is clean.
  • B. That puts the CH₃ on the β-carbon next to the ring: C₆H₅C(CH₃)=CHCHO (3-phenylbut-2-enal). The target has the CH₃ on the α-carbon.
  • C. Phenylacetaldehyde as the donor would put the ring on the α-carbon. In the target, the ring is on the β-carbon.
  • D. That makes cinnamaldehyde, C₆H₅CH=CHCHO, without the CH₃ on the α-carbon.
Problem 13 · Work backwards3-Methylcyclopent-2-en-1-one is made by an intramolecular aldol condensation. What is the starting material?

Show worked solution

Answer: hexane-2,5-dione.

  1. Label the ring: C1 is the C=O, C2 is α (=CH–), and C3 is β (=C–CH₃).
  2. Cut C2=C3. The ring opens into a chain.
  3. Repair: C3 becomes a ketone C=O that still holds its CH₃, and C2 becomes a CH₃ on the other ketone (C1).
  4. The chain is CH₃COCH₂CH₂COCH₃, hexane-2,5-dione. OpenStax 23.6 uses this exact example.

Check: C₆H₁₀O₂ − H₂O = C₆H₈O.

Every option explained

  • A (correct). Cut the ring C=C (C2=C3). C3 gets a C=O and keeps its CH₃, so it becomes a methyl ketone. C2 gets back two H, so it becomes the CH₃ next to the other ketone. Reconnect: CH₃COCH₂CH₂COCH₃.
  • B. It closes a 5-membered ring, but it gives cyclopent-1-ene-1-carbaldehyde, an aldehyde with no CH₃.
  • C. The two C=O groups are too close (1,3). The biggest ring it could make is 4-membered. Its very acidic middle CH₂ just forms a stable enolate.
  • D. That 1,5-diketone closes a 6-membered ring and gives 3-methylcyclohex-2-en-1-one.

Round 6: Ring size (2 problems)

Problem 14 · Ring sizeOctane-2,7-dione, CH₃CO(CH₂)₄COCH₃, is heated with NaOH. What ring size does the main product have?

Show worked solution

Answer: the 5-membered ring, 1-(2-methylcyclopent-1-en-1-yl)ethan-1-one.

  1. Number it: C1 CH₃, C2 C=O, C3–C6 CH₂, C7 C=O, C8 CH₃. The α-carbons are C1, C3, C6 and C8.
  2. C3 → C7 makes a 5-ring (C3, C4, C5, C6, C7). C1 → C7 makes a 7-ring. C6 → C2 and C8 → C2 are the same by symmetry.
  3. The 5-ring wins. Dehydration puts the C=C between C3 and C7, so the ring carries an acetyl group and a CH₃ on neighboring C=C carbons.

Check: C₈H₁₄O₂ − H₂O = C₈H₁₂O.

Every option explained

  • A. It is possible on paper (C1 attacking C7). But a 7-membered ring is less favorable than the 5-membered option, and since every step is reversible, the 5-ring wins.
  • B (correct). C3 (α to the C2 ketone) attacks C7. The ring is C3–C4–C5–C6–C7, five carbons. The C2 acetyl group stays outside the ring.
  • C. No α-carbon here is the right distance from the other C=O to close a 6-membered ring. That product comes from heptane-2,6-dione.
Problem 15 · Ring sizeHexanedial, OHC(CH₂)₄CHO, is heated with NaOH. What is the main product?

Show worked solution

Answer: cyclopent-1-ene-1-carbaldehyde.

  1. The α-carbons are C2 and C5. C2 attacking C6 (or C5 attacking C1, the same thing by symmetry) closes a 5-membered ring.
  2. Addition gives 2-hydroxycyclopentane-1-carbaldehyde, with the OH on the old C6.
  3. Heat: E1cB gives a ring C=C between the carbon holding the CHO and its neighbor.

Check: C₆H₁₀O₂ − H₂O = C₆H₈O.

Every option explained

  • A. That has 7 carbons, but hexanedial has only 6. Count the ring plus the CHO.
  • B. That is the addition product, before water is lost. With heat it dehydrates to the conjugated enal.
  • C (correct). C2 (α to one CHO) attacks C6 (the other CHO). C2–C3–C4–C5–C6 is a 5-ring. Dehydration puts the C=C between C2 and C6, conjugated with the CHO that stays outside the ring.
  • D. A 6-ring would need a bond between C1 and C6. Both are C=O carbons, and neither is an α-carbon, so neither can be the nucleophile.

Round 7: Exam traps (2 problems)

Problem 16 · Exam trapsWhich compound can never be the enolate (donor) in an aldol reaction?

Show worked solution

Answer: 2,2-dimethylpropanal.

Check each compound by finding its C=O, looking at the carbon(s) next to it, and asking whether they carry H. In (CH₃)₃C–CHO the only neighbor is a quaternary carbon. The other common no-α-H carbonyls are formaldehyde, benzaldehyde and benzophenone. All of them can be acceptors only.

Every option explained

  • A. Its CH₂ has two α-hydrogens, and they are extra acidic because the ring helps stabilize the anion. It is a great donor.
  • B. It has four α-hydrogens, two on each side of the C=O.
  • C (correct). The carbon next to the CHO carries three CH₃ groups and has no H. The CH₃ hydrogens are β, not α, so they are not acidic. It can only be an acceptor.
  • D. It has α-H on both sides (CH₃ and CH₂), so it can even make two different enolates.
Problem 17 · Exam trapsWhich reaction is NOT an aldol reaction?

Show worked solution

Answer: ethyl acetate with NaOEt (a Claisen condensation).

The quick test is the product. A β-hydroxy carbonyl or an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl means aldol. A β-keto ester (or a β-diketone made from an ester) means Claisen. In a Claisen the ester’s OR group leaves, and nothing leaves in an aldol addition. OpenStax covers the Claisen in 23.7.

Every option explained

  • A. This is an intramolecular aldol condensation (Problem 13 and OpenStax 23.6).
  • B. This is a Claisen–Schmidt reaction. The name sounds like Claisen, but it is a crossed aldol condensation between a ketone and an aromatic aldehyde.
  • C. That is the textbook aldol addition.
  • D (correct). Esters do a Claisen condensation. The enolate adds to the ester C=O, then ethoxide is kicked out (acyl substitution). The product is a β-keto ester, not a β-hydroxy carbonyl.

Aldol questions show up on almost every Orgo 2 final, usually in synthesis problems. Practice them until the donor and acceptor jump out at you.

Start practicing free

3 days, every chapter. No card.

FAQ

What is the difference between aldol addition and aldol condensation?

Aldol addition stops at the β-hydroxy aldehyde or ketone: the enolate adds to a C=O and the alkoxide is protonated. Aldol condensation goes one step further. With heat, the product loses water by E1cB under basic conditions or by E1/E2 under acidic conditions to give an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl, so the overall reaction joins two molecules and releases H₂O.

Why are α-hydrogens acidic?

Removing an α-hydrogen leaves an enolate, whose negative charge is shared between the α-carbon and the carbonyl oxygen by resonance. That makes ketones about pKa 19 to 20 and aldehydes about 17, much more acidic than ordinary C–H bonds (alkanes are around 60).

Why can hydroxide leave in the dehydration step if it is a poor leaving group?

The dehydration is E1cB. Base first removes the acidic α-hydrogen to make an enolate, and that electron-rich carbanion pushes out the neighboring OH. The new C=C is conjugated with the C=O, which makes the product more stable and helps drive the step.

How do you control a crossed aldol reaction?

Take away choices. Use one partner with no α-hydrogens, such as benzaldehyde or formaldehyde, so it can only be the acceptor. Or use a partner that is much more acidic, like a 1,3-dicarbonyl. Or turn one partner completely into its enolate with LDA at −78 °C before adding the other carbonyl.

How do you predict the ring size in an intramolecular aldol?

Try each α-carbon against the other C=O and count the ring atoms from the attacking carbon to the attacked carbonyl carbon, including both. All the steps are reversible, so the five- or six-membered ring wins over strained three- or four-membered rings and over larger rings.

What is the difference between an aldol and a Claisen condensation?

An aldol joins aldehydes or ketones by nucleophilic addition and keeps the oxygen as OH, or loses it as water. A Claisen joins esters by nucleophilic acyl substitution. The alkoxide leaves, and the product is a β-keto ester.

Ready to check what you just read? Practice Enols and enolates in the app. Chapters 1 and 11 are free with no login; this chapter opens with the free trial (email only, no card).

Try a practice problem now

Sources

The aldol is really one move: an enolate meets a C=O. Practice it until you can draw it without stopping to think.

Start practicing free

3 days, every chapter. No card.