Organic Chemistry II · Aromatic reactions
Electrophilic aromatic substitution practice problems, with directing groups explained
Electrophilic aromatic substitution (EAS) looks like a pile of reagents, but every reaction runs on the same two-step mechanism. Once you can draw the sigma complex and see where its positive charge goes, you can work out directing effects instead of memorizing them. This page builds that one skill, then puts it to work in 16 practice problems: predicting products, ranking rates, ordering synthesis steps and spotting Friedel–Crafts traps.
Jump to: the mechanism · the five reactions · why groups direct · ranked substituent table · two substituents · synthesis order · worked examples · practice problems · FAQ
Want to test yourself first? Practice Aromatic reactions in the app. Chapters 1 and 11 are free with no login; this chapter opens with the free trial (email only, no card).
Try a practice problem nowThe four questions EAS problems ask
Almost every exam question on this chapter is one of these. The practice set at the bottom is sorted the same way, so you can practice whichever one you keep missing.
- 1. What is the electrophile?Each reagent pair exists to make one strong electrophile: Br⁺, NO₂⁺, SO₃H⁺, a carbocation or an acylium ion.
- 2. How fast?Groups that push electrons into the ring speed it up (activating). Groups that pull electrons out slow it down (deactivating).
- 3. Where?The new group goes ortho/para or meta to the old one, depending on which sigma complex is most stable.
- 4. In what order?To make a disubstituted ring, the group you add first decides where the second one lands.
The mechanism: attack, then lose H⁺
Benzene's six π electrons are spread around the ring, which makes it very stable. It won't react with Br₂ alone, the way an alkene does. It needs a much stronger electrophile, and that is what the catalyst is for. Here is bromination, the model for every EAS reaction (OpenStax 16.1).
Step 0.FeBr₃ is a Lewis acid. It grabs one end of Br₂, which makes the other bromine strongly electrophilic. You can treat it as "Br⁺".
Step 1.Two π electrons from the ring attack that bromine, and the Br–Br bond breaks, leaving FeBr₄⁻. The ring is now a carbocation called the arenium ion or sigma complex. It is not aromatic anymore, so this is the slow, rate-limiting step.
In words: the arrow from the ring's C=C goes to Br, and the arrow from the Br–Br bond goes to the bromine held by FeBr₃. The new C–Br carbon is sp³ (it holds both H and Br). The + is shared by the three carbons ortho and para to it. Those three drawings are resonance forms of one ion, not three different ions.
Step 2.A base (FeBr₄⁻ here) removes the H⁺ from the sp³ carbon. The C–H electrons drop back into the ring, aromaticity returns, and you get bromobenzene, HBr, and FeBr₃ back.
In words: the arrow from FeBr₄⁻ goes to the H, and the arrow from the C–H bond goes into the ring to make the C=C that cancels the +. The products are bromobenzene + HBr + FeBr₃.
Why substitution and not addition? If Br⁻ added to the carbocation the way it does with an alkene, the product would lose the ring's aromatic stability. Losing H⁺ restores it, so substitution wins every time.
Need a refresher on drawing these arrows or on resonance forms? See arrow pushing practice problems and resonance structures practice.
The five EAS reactions: what each reagent pair makes
The mechanism never changes. Only the electrophile does. Learn the reagent pair, the electrophile it makes, and the one catch for each.
| Reaction | Reagents | Electrophile | Group added | The catch |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Halogenation | Br₂, FeBr₃ or Cl₂, FeCl₃ (AlCl₃ also works) | "Br⁺" or "Cl⁺" (X₂ held by the Lewis acid) | –Br, –Cl | Iodine needs an oxidizer (H₂O₂ or CuCl₂) to make I⁺. Fluorine is too violent to use directly. |
| Nitration | HNO₃, H₂SO₄ | Nitronium ion, NO₂⁺ | –NO₂ | Later you can reduce –NO₂ to –NH₂ (Fe or SnCl₂ with HCl, or H₂/Pd). That turns a meta director into an ortho/para director. |
| Sulfonation | SO₃, H₂SO₄ (fuming sulfuric acid) | HSO₃⁺ or SO₃ | –SO₃H | Reversible: strong acid puts it on, hot dilute aqueous acid takes it off. That makes it a removable blocking group. |
| Friedel–Crafts alkylation | R–Cl, AlCl₃ | Carbocation, R⁺ (or a complex that acts like one) | –R | Carbocations rearrange; the product is more reactive, so it adds more than once; fails on strongly deactivated rings and on –NH₂/–NHR/–NR₂ rings; aryl and vinyl halides don't work. |
| Friedel–Crafts acylation | RCOCl, AlCl₃ | Acylium ion, R–C≡O⁺ | –COR (a ketone) | No rearrangement and only one addition, because the ketone deactivates the ring. Same ring limits as alkylation. |
For where these come from, see OpenStax 16.2 and 16.3.
Friedel–Crafts: the four ways it goes wrong
- Rearrangement. A primary alkyl halide shifts to a more stable cation before it attacks. With 1-chlorobutane at 0 °C, benzene gives about 2 parts sec-butylbenzene to 1 part butylbenzene (OpenStax 16.3).
- Polyalkylation. The alkyl group you add activates the ring, so the product reacts faster than benzene. A large excess of benzene keeps it to one.
- Dead rings. No reaction on rings carrying a strong electron-withdrawing group (–NO₂, –CN, –SO₃H, any C=O, –NR₃⁺). Amines (–NH₂, –NHR, –NR₂) fail too: the nitrogen lone pair grabs AlCl₃ and becomes a strongly deactivating group. Halogens are weak deactivators, but Friedel–Crafts can still work on halobenzenes.
- Wrong halide. Aryl and vinyl halides (chlorobenzene, vinyl chloride) can't be the alkylating agent, because aryl and vinyl cations are too unstable to form.
The fix for the first two: acylate instead, then reduce the C=O to CH₂. Use Wolff–Kishner (H₂NNH₂, KOH, heat), Clemmensen (Zn(Hg), HCl) or H₂/Pd. H₂/Pd also reduces any –NO₂ on the ring to –NH₂.
Why groups direct: follow the + in the sigma complex
The rule of thumb is that donors send the electrophile ortho/para and withdrawers send it meta. Here's the reason, and it's one idea: the electrophile goes wherever the sigma complex is most stable, because that step is the slow one.
When E adds to a carbon, the + ends up on the carbons ortho and para to that carbon. So for ortho or para attack, one resonance form always puts the + right on the carbon holding the substituent. For meta attack, it never does. Whether that form is good or bad news decides everything:
- Lone-pair donors (–OH, –OR, –NH₂, –NHCOR): the lone pair forms a C=O⁺ or C=N⁺ bond and gives a fourth resonance form where every atom has an octet. Ortho/para is favored, and the ring is faster than benzene.
- Alkyl groups: that form is a tertiary carbocation, so ortho/para is favored, and the ring is a little faster.
- Withdrawers (–NO₂, –CN, –SO₃H, C=O groups, –CF₃, –NR₃⁺): that form puts + right next to an atom that is already positive or δ+. It is very unstable, so ortho/para attack is worst. Meta is the least bad, and the ring is slower than benzene.
- Halogens: the odd case. Their electronegativity pulls electrons out through the sigma bond (induction), so the ring is slower than benzene. But a halogen lone pair can still share the + at ortho/para, so those positions win. They are deactivating but ortho/para directing.
See it with anisole (methoxybenzene)
Para attack: the second form puts + on the carbon holding OCH₃ (circled), so the oxygen can donate a lone pair and make a fourth form with C=O⁺. Four forms, one with full octets: low energy.
Meta attack: the + lands on the other three carbons, never the one holding OCH₃. Only three forms, so meta attack is much slower.
Sigma complex explorer
Pick a group and an attack position. The explorer draws every resonance form of the sigma complex and circles the one that decides the answer.
| Group | Ortho or para attack | Meta attack | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| –OCH₃, –OH, –NH₂ | Yes, and the lone pair adds a fourth form (good) | No | Ortho/para, faster than benzene |
| –CH₃ and other alkyls | Yes, a tertiary cation (good) | No | Ortho/para, a bit faster |
| –F, –Cl, –Br, –I | Yes, and a lone pair adds a fourth form (helps a little) | No | Ortho/para, but slower than benzene |
| –NO₂, –CN, C=O groups | Yes, + next to a positive atom (bad) | No | Meta, slower than benzene |
Ranked substituent table
Strongest activator at the top, strongest deactivator at the bottom. The last column shows how the product splits when that monosubstituted benzene is nitrated (HNO₃/H₂SO₄, 25 °C, from OpenStax Table 16.1). For scale: –OH makes the ring about 1000 times faster than benzene, and –NO₂ makes it more than 10 million times slower.
| Group | Effect on rate | Directs | How it works | Nitration % ortho / meta / para |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| –NH₂, –NHR, –NR₂, –OH, –O⁻ | Strongly activating | Ortho/para | Lone pair donates strongly into the ring | –OH: 50 / 0 / 50 |
| –OR, –NHCOR, –OCOR | Moderately activating | Ortho/para | Lone pair donates, but part of it is pulled toward the C=O (amide, ester) or the O is less generous | –NHCOCH₃: 19 / 2 / 79 |
| –R (alkyl), –C₆H₅ | Weakly activating | Ortho/para | Donates a little; stabilizes the tertiary-type cation form | –CH₃: 63 / 3 / 34 |
| –H (benzene) | Reference | None | – | – |
| –F, –Cl, –Br, –I | Weakly deactivating | Ortho/para | Pulls by induction (rate down), but lone pair helps ortho/para | –Cl: 35 / 1 / 64; –Br: 43 / 1 / 56 |
| –CHO, –COR, –CO₂R, –CO₂H, –CONH₂ | Moderately deactivating | Meta | C=O pulls electrons out of the ring by resonance and induction | –COCH₃: 26 / 72 / 2; –CO₂CH₃: 28 / 66 / 6 |
| –CN, –SO₃H, –CF₃, –NO₂, –NR₃⁺ | Strongly deactivating | Meta | Strong pull, or a full + right next to the ring | –CN: 17 / 81 / 2; –NO₂: 7 / 91 / 2 |
Two shortcuts fall out of the table. There are no meta-directing activators. And every deactivator except the halogens is a meta director. OpenStax calls all the meta directors strongly deactivating; many courses split them into "moderate" (carbonyls) and "strong" (nitro and friends) like this table does, and the order within a row rarely matters on exams.
Rings that already have two groups
Three rules cover nearly every case (OpenStax 16.5):
- If the groups agree, easy. In 4-nitrotoluene, CH₃ wants its ortho carbons, and those are meta to NO₂, which is exactly where NO₂ wants it. Bromination gives 2-bromo-4-nitrotoluene.
- If they disagree, the stronger activator wins (higher in the table above), though you often get some of the other product. In 4-methylphenol, –OH beats –CH₃, so bromine goes ortho to the OH.
- Skip the spot between two meta groups. In a 1,3-disubstituted ring, C2 sits between both groups. It is too crowded, so substitution rarely happens there even when both groups point at it.
And when the stronger group is only slightly stronger (–CH₃ vs –Cl, say), expect a mixture. Exam questions usually avoid those cases, or they ask you to say "mixture".
Synthesis order: plan backward from the target
For a disubstituted target, look at how the two groups sit relative to each other, then ask which one must already be on the ring to steer the other into place.
- Meta target? Put the meta director on first. Ortho or para target? Put the ortho/para director on first, then separate the ortho and para isomers (para is usually easier to isolate pure).
- Friedel–Crafts goes early, before any –NO₂, –SO₃H or C=O is on the ring, and never on an aniline.
- Use groups that change roles.
- Acyl → alkyl. Wolff–Kishner, Clemmensen or H₂/Pd turns a meta-directing C=O into an ortho/para-directing CH₂. This also gets straight-chain alkyl groups without rearrangement.
- –NO₂ → –NH₂. Reduction turns a strong meta director into a strong ortho/para director.
- –CH₃ → –CO₂H. Hot KMnO₄ oxidizes any alkyl group with a benzylic H to –CO₂H, turning ortho/para into meta (OpenStax 16.8). tert-Butyl has no benzylic H, so it survives.
- –SO₃H as a blocking group. Put it on para (separate the para sulfonation isomer), do the reaction you want at ortho, then remove it with hot dilute acid.
Synthesis questions on a final often mix this with Orgo 1 reactions. For alkene steps, keep the alkene reactions cheat sheet open.
Worked examples
Example 1: Nitration of toluene, start to finish
Question: Toluene reacts with HNO₃ and H₂SO₄. What is the electrophile, where does it go, and why?
- Make the electrophile. Sulfuric acid is the stronger acid, so it puts a proton on the OH group of nitric acid. Losing water then leaves the nitronium ion: HNO₃ + H₂SO₄ → H₂NO₃⁺ + HSO₄⁻, then H₂NO₃⁺ → NO₂⁺ + H₂O.
- Classify the group. –CH₃ is a weak activator and an ortho/para director, so toluene reacts somewhat faster than benzene.
- Check the sigma complex. Attack ortho or para to CH₃ gives one resonance form with + on the carbon holding the CH₃. That form is a tertiary carbocation, which the methyl stabilizes. Meta attack gives only secondary-cation forms.
- Finish the mechanism. HSO₄⁻ (or water) removes the H⁺ from the sp³ carbon, and the ring is aromatic again.
Answer: a mixture of 2-nitrotoluene and 4-nitrotoluene, with almost no 3-nitrotoluene (OpenStax: 63% ortho, 3% meta, 34% para).
Check: 63 + 3 + 34 = 100. Why more ortho than para? There are two ortho carbons and only one para. Per carbon it's 63 ÷ 2 = 31.5% at each ortho site vs 34% at para, so para is actually slightly favored site for site.
Example 2: Two groups that disagree
Question: Predict the major product when 4-methylanisole (1-methoxy-4-methylbenzene) is nitrated.
- Label the groups. –OCH₃ at C1 is a moderate activator (ortho/para). –CH₃ at C4 is a weak activator (ortho/para).
- List where each one points. OCH₃: C2 and C6 (its para spot, C4, is taken). CH₃: C3 and C5 (its para spot, C1, is taken). They disagree.
- The stronger activator wins. –OCH₃ is higher in the ranked table, so the nitro group goes to C2 (C6 is the same by symmetry).
- Check sterics. C2 sits between OCH₃ and an H, not between two groups, so nothing blocks it.
Answer: 4-methyl-2-nitroanisole (1-methoxy-4-methyl-2-nitrobenzene), plus a little of the isomer with NO₂ next to the CH₃.
Check: the product still has OCH₃ and CH₃ para to each other. Only one ring H was replaced, and the formula goes from C₈H₁₀O to C₈H₉NO₃.
Example 3: m-bromonitrobenzene vs p-bromonitrobenzene from benzene
Question: Same two reagents, two different targets. Which order gives which?
- Meta target. –NO₂ is the meta director, so it goes on first: HNO₃/H₂SO₄ gives nitrobenzene. Then Br₂/FeBr₃ with heat puts Br meta. Nitrobenzene bromination needs harsher conditions because the ring is strongly deactivated; Friedel–Crafts does not work.
- Para target. –Br is the ortho/para director, so it goes on first: Br₂/FeBr₃ gives bromobenzene. Then HNO₃/H₂SO₄ nitrates ortho and para.
- Deal with the mixture. Bromobenzene nitrates 43% ortho, 1% meta and 56% para (OpenStax Table 16.1), so you separate the para isomer from the ortho one.
Answer: meta = nitrate, then brominate. Para = brominate, then nitrate (and separate the isomers).
Check: in each route, the first group really does direct the second where the target needs it. NO₂ is meta-directing, and Br is ortho/para-directing (meta is only 1%).
Example 4: Propylbenzene without the rearrangement
Question: Why can't you make propylbenzene from benzene, 1-chloropropane and AlCl₃? What works instead?
- Spot the trap. 1-Chloropropane with AlCl₃ behaves like a primary carbocation. A 1,2-hydride shift turns it into the more stable isopropyl cation, so you get a lot of isopropylbenzene (cumene). The alkylated ring is also more reactive than benzene, so some of it gets alkylated again.
- Acylate instead. Propanoyl chloride (CH₃CH₂COCl) with AlCl₃ gives the acylium ion CH₃CH₂C≡O⁺, which doesn't rearrange. The product is propiophenone (1-phenylpropan-1-one), and the ketone deactivates the ring, so it stops at one.
- Reduce the C=O to CH₂. Use H₂/Pd (OpenStax 16.9 uses this exact example), Wolff–Kishner (H₂NNH₂, KOH, heat; OpenStax 19.9) or Clemmensen (Zn(Hg), HCl).
Answer: CH₃CH₂COCl/AlCl₃, then reduce the ketone. You get propylbenzene with an unbranched three-carbon chain.
Check: count the carbons. The acyl group brings 3 (C=O plus CH₂CH₃), and after reduction the chain is CH₂CH₂CH₃, still 3 carbons in a row. That's C₉H₁₂, the same as cumene but a different skeleton.
Practice problems
Sixteen problems in four types. Pick a type to focus on, or work straight through. Every problem gives instant feedback and has a full solution. Your score counts first tries only, so guess-and-check doesn't inflate it.
Directing groups click after a few dozen reps, not one read. Practice aromatic reactions and every other Orgo chapter with feedback on each step.
Start practicing free3 days, every chapter. No card.
FAQ
What is the difference between activating and deactivating groups?
An activating group pushes electron density into the ring, which stabilizes the positively charged sigma complex, so the ring reacts faster than benzene. A deactivating group pulls electron density out, so the ring reacts slower. Every activator directs ortho/para. Every deactivator except the halogens directs meta.
Why are halogens deactivating but ortho/para directors?
Halogens are electronegative, so they pull electrons out of the ring through the sigma bond, which slows every position down. But they also have lone pairs that can share the positive charge when the electrophile adds ortho or para, which meta attack can never use. The pull sets the rate, and the lone pair sets the position.
Why doesn't Friedel–Crafts work on nitrobenzene or aniline?
A strongly electron-withdrawing group like nitro makes the ring too poor a nucleophile to attack a carbocation or acylium ion. In aniline, the basic nitrogen reacts with the AlCl₃ catalyst, and the complex it forms is strongly deactivating. Halogen-substituted rings still work.
How do I choose which group to add first in a synthesis?
Look at whether the two groups in the target are meta or ortho/para to each other. Add the group that directs to that relationship first. Also do any Friedel–Crafts step before adding a strong deactivator, and remember tricks like acylation followed by reduction, nitro reduction to an amine, and SO₃H as a removable blocking group.
Is ortho or para usually the major product?
Para is often the major product because the ortho positions sit next to the existing group and are more crowded, especially with bulky groups. There are two ortho positions, though, so small groups like methyl can give more ortho overall. Toluene nitration gives 63% ortho and 34% para.
Ready to check what you just read? Practice Aromatic reactions in the app. Chapters 1 and 11 are free with no login; this chapter opens with the free trial (email only, no card).
Try a practice problem nowSources
- OpenStax Organic Chemistry, Chapter 16: 16.1 Bromination, 16.2 Other Aromatic Substitutions, 16.3 The Friedel–Crafts Reaction, 16.4 Substituent Effects (Table 16.1 nitration data) and 16.5 Trisubstituted Benzenes
- OpenStax Organic Chemistry, 16.8 Oxidation of Aromatic Compounds, 16.9 Reduction of Aromatic Compounds and 16.10 Synthesis of Polysubstituted Benzenes
- OpenStax Organic Chemistry, 19.9 The Wolff–Kishner Reaction
- LibreTexts, Clemmensen Reduction (Zn(Hg), HCl for aryl alkyl ketones)
Most points on an aromatic chemistry exam come from the same four questions. Practice them until the answer shows up before you draw the arrows.
Start practicing free3 days, every chapter. No card.